Guides

8 Best Breast Pump Reviews 2017 Compared– (Pros and Cons)

Selecting the best breast pump 2017 is important for your comfort during the pumping process and your baby's health when consuming the expressed product. If you select a poor quality pump, you could end up with sore, inflamed breasts that are tender to the touch and painful during feedings. You may also end up with low suction quality which means you have to pump longer or will be unable to express the amount of milk your baby needs for consistent, satisfying feedings.

The best way to make sure your chosen breast pump meets every need for you and your baby is to read breast pump reviews. The comparison chart and shoppers guide featured right here will help you size up the best pumps on the market today. Using this resource, you can rest assured that you are bringing home the best breast pump for this delicate part of your body and that baby you love.

What to Look for with Todays Market

The first decision you must make when shopping for a breast pump is whether you want to go with a manual, electric or battery-powered pump. Manual pumps are the cheapest and are often the quietest, but they also require more work on your part. Electric and battery-powered pumps are more convenient and many women find them easier to use and more comfortable. Most women now go with an electric pump, but there are still some circumstances where manual pumps are the best option.

You will also have to decide whether you want a double or single pump. This refers to either pumping one breast at a time or having the option to pump both breasts simultaneously. Some women find that when one breast is pumped, the other breast naturally starts to express milk. You can solve that problem and save yourself a lot of time by purchasing a double pump.

The quality and price point of your breast pump will also play a big part in your buying decision. There are some hospital-grade pumps on the market with high price tags, but they are typically used only by women who experience extreme difficulties feeding their babies. If you need to feed a preemie or you struggle to get your milk flowing due to infrequent breastfeeding sessions due to your babys health, you may consider this higher quality grade essential.

If your baby feeds without problem or you need to watch your budget, there are many high quality breast pumps that will meet your needs without the hospital grade designation. Do not assume that the highest priced pumps are always the best pumps. Determine the maximum amount that you can afford to spend on this investment, and then shop for pumps within or slightly above that budget limit. You can sometimes find higher priced pumps on sale if you shop online, so dont rule a pump out until you shop around a bit.

Here is a table with the most appreciated breast pumps:

PRODUCT
PRODUCT DIMENSIONS
BATTERIES REQUIRED
PRICE
OUR RATING
BEST PRICE ON:
Medela Pump in Style Advanced Backpack Medela Pump in Style Advanced Backpack 6.5 x 15.5 x 11.2 inches No $$$ A+ bnair
Philips Avent Double Electric Comfort Breast Pump Philips Avent Double Electric Comfort Breast Pump 1 x 1 x 1 inches No $$$ A+ bnair
The First Years miPumpMedela Swing Breastpump 11 x 5.8 x 9 inches Yes $$ A bnair
Medela Freestyle Breast PumpMedela Freestyle Breast Pump 18 x 8 x 12 inches Yes $$$ A+ bnair
Lansinoh Affinity Double Electric Breast Pump Lansinoh Affinity Double Electric Breast Pump (BPA-Free) 15.1 x 9.4 x 8.2 inches No $$$ A bnair
The Ameda Purely Yours Ultra Breast Pumpmp Lansinoh Affinity Double Electric Breast Pump (BPA-Free) 15.9 x 8 x 11.3 inches Yes $$$ A bnair
Philips AVENT BPA Free Manual Breast PumpLansinoh Affinity Double Electric Breast Pump (BPA-Free) 7.9 x 3.5 x 8.7 inches Yes $$ B+ bnair
Medela Harmony Manual Breast PumpLansinoh Affinity Double Electric Breast Pump (BPA-Free) 9.1 x 7.3 x 3.6 inches No $$ B+ bnair

Recommended Best Breast pump 2017

If you’re looking for the best breast pump of 2017, here are some of the top rated and reviewed products in the market today.

Razor Pocket Mod Miniature Euro Electric Scooter

Editor's Rating:

This pump is proudly made in USA; and is comprised of hard BPA-free plastic materials that are strong and sturdy. The unit also comes with bottle holders – this design will help avoid accidental spills.

Since the Medela Pump in Style Advanced Breast Pump comes with a tote bag, you can easily bring it to work or anywhere else. And if you’re using it at home, the tote bag can serve as its handy storage place.​

As this Medela pump functions on AC/DC, you can use it by plugging it into a wall outlet. Alternatively, you can choose to use batteries. It uses your standard size AA alkaline batteries.

With its two-phase expression technology and 1-touch let down button, extracting milk is not only fast and efficient but comfortable too. Measuring 14.2 x 7.2 x 11.5 inches, the pump is very easy to manage.

The package is complete and it works right out of the box, so you can use it right away. Aside from the breast pump, you also get an AC adapter, cooler bag and ice pack, battery pack, breast milk bottles (5-oz), personal fit connectors, 24mm breast shields, tubing, valves, and an instruction manual.

It is highly advisable to thoroughly read the instruction manual first before operating it. This way, you’ll know how to properly use it and you’ll figure out which parts go where when assembling it for the first time. Remember, it is an electrical model, and mishandling or misusing it can result in damage.

Although the price may be steep for some, this top-end model boasts an extreme amount of quality, making it one of the best breast pump 2017.

Pros

    • Integrated pump
    • Microfiber backpack
    • Battery pack without any batteries
    • Cooler bag with contoured ice pack
    • All parts are BPA-free
    • Speed and vacuum adjustments
    • One-touch let down button
    • Four (4) 5-ounce bottles
    • Four (4) membranes
    • One (1) tubing set
    • Two (2) valves
    • Two (2) PersonalFIt connectors

Cons

  • The Medela Pump in Style Advanced is an open system. So the milk can get into the tubes.
  • In some cases, the battery provided may not work properly
 Swagger Lightest Carbon Fiber Electric Scooter

Editor's Rating:

The Philips AVENT Double Electric Comfort Breast Pump offers comfort and efficiency when extracting milk from breasts. The pump’s design and structure is made in such a way that more milk is expressed in a shorter period of time than most other makes/models.

It is made of plastic materials which are BPA-free, so it’s safe for both the mommy and the baby. This gives added peace of mind, knowing that there aren’t any harmful elements.

Additionally, there’s a built-in massage cushion that gently stimulates the breasts to produce milk. With this design, milk will flow naturally and painlessly.

It measures 13 x 6 x 10.5 inches and is equipped with only a few parts. Assembling and operating it is therefore easy and trouble-free.

The Philips AVENT Double Electric Comfort Breast Pump is so convenient and comfortable to use that you can even opt to extract milk from both of your breasts at the same time. There are 3 flow settings to choose from, so you can opt for the setting that’s most comfortable for you.

Operating the unit simply involves pressing and pushing buttons, so you won’t find it confusing and hard to manage. It’s this relaxed environment while using the device that will further allow for comfortable milk extraction.

Pros

    • Philips AVENT Twin Electric Breast Pump
    • Four (4) bottle stands/funnel covers
    • Two (2) 4-ounce milk containers
    • Two (2) flow nipples for newborns
    • Two (2) travel packs
    • Microfiber travel bag
    • Two (2) sealing discs
    • Spares parts
    • Instruction guide
    • Soft massage cushions
    • Electric memory
    • One-touch memory

Cons

  • Assemble is little harder
  • Requires new Avent bottles to work.
  • Milk might drip down from the cushion
IMAX S1 Electric Scooter

Editor's Rating:

Unnatural milk extraction can be uncomfortable and painful; which is why breast pumps are made to mimic a baby’s natural suckling motions. If you’re considering getting a breast pump, The First Years miPump Double Electric Breast Pump is one of the best choices on the market in 2017.

It comes with flexible-it breast shields, so it will fit most any size breast of lactating mothers. Aside from being soft, the breast shields can conform to the specific size and shape of mother’s breasts, making it a soft and cozy fit that isn’t cumbersome and uncomfortable.

Assembly is easy as there are only a few parts to set up in order for it to function. Using and managing it is just as easy; and the built-in handle frees up one of your hands so that you can do other things while pumping milk from your breast.

While other models of breast pumps can be a little noisy, the miPump Double Electric Breast Pump is quiet and discreet. It’s quite embarrassing to let people know that you are pumping milk from your breasts especially if you are in a public place, so having a quiet feature is certainly a plus.

The LED display lets you program and monitor your desired settings while in use. You also have the option to adjust the suction levels through the control system, giving you a custom-like feel while operating.

Measuring 11 x 5.8 x 9 inches, this breast pump is compact and manageable even if you decide to take it outside your home. In fact, it even comes with a stylish carrying bag which also serves as its storage when you’re not using it.

This is an AC/DC model so you can choose to plug it into an outlet, or run it on 4 AA batteries. The First Years miPump Double Electric Breast Pump is extremely affordable.

Pros

    • Quick assembly and simple to use
    • Comes in single and double pump sets
    • Convenient adjustable levels of suction
    • LED display for easy reading in the dark
    • Compact and efficient for busy moms
    • Patented handle allows you to keep one hand free while pumping
    • Durable yet nice looking tote
    • Comfortable “Flexi-fit” breast shield
    • Eight adjustable suction settings
    • 3-way adapter compatible with all bottle brands
    • Lightweight, compact pump motor
    • Includes a 90-day manufacturer’s warranty
    • Two easy-pour milk storage bags and two lanolin nursing pads are included

Cons

  • The rubber shields are not gentle on skin during use resulting in friction & soreness
  • The different settings only adjust the suction, not the speed (which is slow)
  • This pump requires wide necked bottles to catch milk, instead of the more convenient and thin flip-top storage bottles that are more popular
  • Each time the motor releases suction, there was a very loud “popping” noise which is very annoying.
EcoReco M5 E-Scooter

Editor's Rating:

It is a breakthrough in breast pumps. One of the best breast pump of 2017. It is efficient and easy to use. It is the company’s first hands-free yet double-electric pump. The size is pretty much perfect as it sized in a way that it can fit in your hand’s palm. It is still full of innovations as it delivers power and offers quite a performance.

The Freestyle Breast Pump is one of those pumps that offer mothers convenience while they are on the go. Mobility, flexibility and freedom are the three main functions Medela was trying to offer its customers and they have succeeded in doing so to a very large extent.

The fact that it is follows a hands-free operation, it becomes more user-friendly as well as removing the use of complex accessories. It weighs less than a pound which makes it easy to move around. The technology that Medela used in its product is breath-taking.

There is a two-phase expression as of now that makes it really advanced. It creates a pumping pattern that imitates the same nursing rhythm that a baby already possesses. It works in two modes, the simulation mode and expression mode.

The simulation mode creates your baby to start sucking which then, of course, starts the milk flow. The other mode, on the other hand, simulates the baby’s slower and deeper suckling to express the milk efficiently and gently.

The Medela Freestyle has a rechargeable battery which allows people to use it for three hours of pure pumping on an entire charge. The battery helps to make the pump accessible in areas where you do not have access to power sockets etc.

The LCD has digital display that lights up when you need to be notified of something. The display is very clear and easy to read. Moms can also save their pumping pattern for the babies if they want to follow the same patter in the future.

Pros

    • Double breast pump for simultaneous expression
    • Includes extra breast shields and spare parts
    • Patented two-phase technology that encourages let-down
    • Convenient, lightweight and easy to travel with
    • Easy to read LCD lighted display for those midnight feedings
    • Unique memory button feature that recalls personal settings
    • Hands-free operation

Cons

    • Multiple pieces to wash/sanitize after each use
    • Considerably loud
    • Fairly expensive
    • Less efficient than other Medela models
    • Many negative reports of low or no suction powe
Lansinoh Affinity Double Electric Breast Pump (BPA-Free)

Editor's Rating:

There are different reasons as to why women would consider a certain breast pump to be fantastic or world-class, but then there are some general characteristics that any breast pumping kit must have: comfort, natural-feeling, portability, durability etc. All of these features are available in the Lansinoh Affinity Double Electric Breast Pump.

It comes with all of the features that a mother would want to have in a pumping kit, which makes it perfect for the present day breastfeeding mother. The pump has been designed specifically for daily use and that too for a long-term be it at home or when you are away. The patented pumping system prevents milk from flowing back into the tubing, a trait that is favorable by many.

Just like any other Lansinoh breast pump, there are a certain number of features that you will always get. At the very beginning of this list, we have that fact that it is BPA-free. This means that mothers do not have to fear about washing it in the dishwasher etc.

Vacuum and cycle speeds can be adjusted according to their own requirements. It is pre-assembled and this makes it more of an ease to use. The closed system makes it easier to clean as there is no milk backflow.

From customer experiences, after using Lansinoh Affinity they decided to push all other breast pumps off of the table. Mothers who experienced Lansinoh’s capabilities, they were more than satisfied regarding the amount of milk that was pumped along with the functioning of it.

The only problem people had was the fact that they didn’t adjust their suction and speed settings and that was only because they were not aware of this feature. The price is justified by the level of quality they are providing, even though most people though it was over-priced.

However, the one thing you would want to check before buying the breast pump is the size of your chest because it is not suitable for the large-chested.

Pros

    • Easy assembly, usage, and simple to clean
    • ​Convenient one-touch operation let-down button
    • ​ComfortFit TM breast flanges allow for a comfortable yet secure fit
    • ​Compact and lightweight for easy travel
    • Affordable price for high quality pump
    • Multiple speed and suction settings
    • Built-in stand to hold bottles preventing spills/loss of milk
    • All components are 100% BPA Free
    • Outstanding “live” customer service and a one year warranty

Cons

  • Does not come with carrying bag like most brands
  • Many consumers complain about low suction
  • Pump motor is reported by some consumers as loud
  • Using the pump in battery mode reduces suction/power
Pulse Performance Products Reverb Electric Scooter

Editor's Rating:

Inspired by moms, the Ameda Purely Yours Ultra Breast Pump offers mothers the most in terms of flexibility, styling and convenience. This breast pump is lightweight and offers you the professional performance, making it easy to care for, no matter where you are or go.

If you decide to use the all new UltraTote, which is the ultra-suede and faux leather bag, it will compliment your wardrobe and at the same time, it will store all of your pumping requirements.

The UltraTote bag will hide and store all of accessories with sophistication. The bag features qualities like easy to clean interior and pockets with dividers to help you stay organized.

The Purely Yours Ultra Breast Pump also uses a HygieniKit Milk Collection System, a system we have mentioned several times before in preceding articles. This is a system where the pump using a patented diaphragm that helps to prevent milk and moisture from finding its way in from the pumping tubes.

Having such a feature helps to save time in regards to cleaning. Also, it is BPA-free which means it is even safe to use with a dishwasher.

You are provided with several various options for your pump, which makes it more efficient for you. Its adjustability quality allows mother to choose the combo that helps pump the most milk. The controls are independently adjusted to one another so you can better prepare yourself for your baby’s natural rhythm of nursing.

The Ameda Purely Yours system was created to assist working mothers in milk collection comfortably and efficiently. With eight suction levels and four cycle speeds, this pump does just that. This is a closed system with a patented diaphragm to prevent moisture from contaminating the pump’s tubes.

Not only can the mother can express milk when it’s convenient, on her schedule but she can rest assured the milk she is providing is safe from bacteria caused from possible cross contamination.

Pros

  • Very lightweight making it easy to transport and use on the go
  • You can express both sides simultaneously
  • Comes with a tote bag 
  • Several power options
  • Inexpensively priced compared with other double pump sets
  • Multiple suction levels and speeds making it more comfortable for the mother
  • The different size flanges and cooler bag are convenient
  • Can be easily converted to a manual pump if needed

Cons

  • Unit has a recurring beep that occurs relative to the suction speed that can be quite annoying
  • The valves can be quite fragile and wear out requiring replacement.
  • It can be difficult to find the same exact setting each time you nurse which can be frustrating.
Pulse Performance Sonic XL Electric Scooter

Editor's Rating:

The Avent Manual Breast Pump is extremely convenient. For those new mothers looking for a safe, extremely effective pumping solution, this is a great buy. Avent specifically researches and manufactures baby products inspired by nature. They pride themselves on creating products that mimic real life actions and feelings. This pump is no exception. Labeled as “whisper quiet”, this pump not only works well but it’s extremely discreet.

Avent is a respected company that has been in business for over 25 years. For those looking for a safe, fast and low-cost best breast pump 2017, this is a great choice. The manual pumps also work with the Avent electric pump should you choose to move to an electric pump. Having compatible equipment is very convenient should you have a problem and need extra replacement parts at odd hours or anytime when you simply can’t wait. It also means you have a back-up pump waiting that you’re comfortable with already should the electricity go out in a storm.

Manual breast pumps are significantly less expensive than motorized electric pumps. Experts agree that manual pumps are the best choice for occasional pumpers or for occasional use outside the home. I was surprised at the number of consumer reviews that indicated they use this pump full-time and still love it.

The main difference of course is manual pumps are more labor-intensive. It’s also impressive to note Avent includes free additional parts (that are lost frequently) inside every package already when you purchase it. This is quite convenient. Even if you never need the part, the piece-of-mind is worth a lot.

Pros

  • Lightweight and travel ready
  • All parts are 100% BPA free
  • Can be used anywhere – discreet and silent
  • Full control over speed and suction intensity
  • Impressive suction power
  • Convenient to collect milk in same bottle you feed with
  • Unit is whisper quiet–so silent and discreet, you can pump anywhere

Cons

  • Have to use Avent bottles, no choice
  • Several small parts to wash – more time to assemble as well
  • Unit is top heavy and can fall over easily
  • The massage cushion can get milk under it
Razor Trikke E2 Electric Scooter

Editor's Rating:

The Medela Harmony is one of the highest rated manual breast pumps around today. While it’s not specifically designed for mother’s that pump exclusively, many mothers use it for that exact purpose.

This popular pump is the only manual pump that utilizes Medela’s special patented “Two Phase Natural Expression technology” which is specifically created to give you maximum results with minimal time and effort.

Medela’s special technology was first introduced with their Symphony breast pump which is also very popular. What makes it unique is that fact that it uses special sets of rhythmic patterns that creatively imitate the real feeling of a baby nursing.

It begins in let-down mode (meaning very rapid suction), then two minutes later, it changes and the flow changes to a more established deep, slow rhythm, more consistent with a baby’s actual nursing habits. One suggestion that can really help with the comfort aspect of pumping is the size of your breast shield. Luckily, Medela makes different sized breast shields. The one supplied with the Harmony is their medium size. Try different sizes, it can really make a huge difference if the shield is not properly fitted to your body.

The Medela Harmony breast pump comes with one 5-ounce bottle. Medela bottles and lids are interchangeable. Also included with this pump are: One 24 mm (medium) PersonalFit™ breast shield, one valve and membrane (plus 2 spare membranes), bottle stand, plus the breastfeeding information guide/ instructions.

Pros

    • Consumers report better production amounts than some electric models (about 5-10 mins to get 2-4oz.)
    • Can pump one-handed while holding baby which stimulates production
    • Specifically designed for quicker let-down which stimulates milk production
    • Very lightweight and portable = 1 pound and fits in a ziploc bag
    • Great for use as a backup to your double electric pump
    • Extremely quiet and fast
    • Easy to clean with minimal parts
    • Evenflo and Dr. Brown’s bottles fit with this pump and quickly adapts to the Playtex drop in system

Cons

    • 30 day limited warranty
    • Inadequate seals, leaks when tipped at all
    • Small “o-ring” seal on pump is very easy to lose while cleaning is not replaceable on its own, you must replace the entire stem which is expensive and only available online from manufacturer.

Final Verdict

Breast Pumps are very essential in order to maintain a steady supply of Breast Milk for your child even while you are away. Some of the major things to look out for in choosing a good Breast Pump are the options for powering it, how comfortable it is in usage, the portability, the durability, the Motor Noise Level and its effectiveness.

Well there you have it. We’ve discovered the top eight, best breast pump 2017 based on consumer reviews, quality, price, and other important factors. Ultimately, the decision on which specific breast pump to buy is all up to you. We hope that we’ve given you a great place to start your search for the best one!

Load More Related Articles

Check Also

Best Electric Breast Pump Reviews of 2017- Side by Side Comparison

Becoming a mother is a wonderful thing. Some ...